In 1958, or shortly before, Mrs. Ben Compton compiled a list of those buried in the Stone’s Chapel cemetery as taken from the headstone inscriptions. The index below was transcribed from a copy of her typewritten list. Please note that if the birthdate is italicized, it was calculated from information in the headstone inscription.
| Last Name | First Name | Born | Died |
| Allemong | Christian | 21 April 1835 (1855?) | |
| Allemong | Ruth | 8 October 1825 | |
| Bennett | George | 8 May 1850 | 31 December 1873 |
| Bennett | George | 17 February 1878 | 2 August 1879 |
| Bennett | Gilbert | 20 January 1882 | 29 January 1882 |
| Bennett | Harry | 24 November 1899 | 10 December 1899 |
| Bennett | Lindian Pearl | 31 Dec 1891 | 22 July 1892 |
| Bennett | Mary Elizabeth | 1 April 1829 | 13 March 1849 |
| Bennett | Peter | c. 1815 | 10 March 1881 |
| Bennett | Phoebe | c. 1816 | 20 January 1894 |
| Blue | Margaret | 27 January 1839 | 10 February 1861 |
| Boggs | Mary Catherine | 15 November 1843 | 9 June 1918 |
| Bowen | Anna | 2 August 1780 | 8 June 1816 |
| Bowen | Anna | 16 June 1766 | 22 April 1840 |
| Bowen | Sarah E. | 16 November 1809 | 23 October 1849 |
| Brown | Thomas | ||
| Bush | Eva O. | 20 January 1895 | 28 July 1895 |
| Carper | Smith, Jr. | 29 November 1907 | 3 August 1908 |
| Carter | Bettie T. | 12 January 1856 | 20 September 1933 |
| Carter | Carrie Price | 1866 | 1878 |
| Carter | Estalla Monroe | 1868 | 1878 |
| Carter | Franklin B. | 10 April 1832 | 19 February 1895 |
| Carter | Ida E. | 19 December 1848 | 17 October 1856 |
| Carter | Laurence P. | 28 July 1845 | 7 March 1866 |
| Carter | Louie J. | 15 February 1872 | 11 December 1939 |
| Carter | Lucy T. | 13 April 1834 | 20 March 1898 |
| Carter | Rosa B. | 7 July 1863 | 3 November 1893 |
| Colston | Elizabeth B. | 19 April 1774 | 19 January 1831 |
| Colston | William | 1805 | 1866 |
| Dutterer | 21 August 1890 | 11 December 1890 | |
| Dutterer | January 1877 | April 1878 | |
| Ellyett | H. Lee | 21 September 1854 | 2 August 1887 |
| Ellyett | James R. | 28 August 1842 | 23 March 1913 |
| Ellyett | Jemina K. | 18 June 1846 | 28 February 1925 |
| Fellers | John James William Taylor | 25 January 1850 | 14 February 1852 |
| Fultz | Elidia | 6 March 1780 | 26 December 1840 |
| Fultz | George | 10 March 1785 | 20 October 1852 |
| Fuqua | Charles C. | 9 August 187? | 9 February 1888 |
| Fuqua | Hattie L. | 29 August 1885 | 9 March 1888 |
| Fuqua | Rosey M. | 23 July 1883 | |
| Gordon | Louisa M. | 24 December 1876 | 6 October 1884 |
| Grant | Henry Adolphus | 3 August 1854 | |
| Grove | Catherine Wolfe | c. 1856 | 6 August 1886 |
| Grove | David | c. 1785 | 23 September 1824 |
| Grubbs | Annie E. | 10 July 1876 | 26 April 1918 |
| Grubbs | Lewis W. | 10 July 1897 | 23 July 1898 |
| Hardesty | Anne A. | 9 March 1834 | 4 April 1849 |
| Hardesty | Mary W. | 22 October 1823 | 11 July 1861 |
| Hardesty | Minnie F. | 5 August 1863 | 16 September 1891 |
| Hardesty | Sarah | 2 February 1816 | 29 August 1870 |
| Hardesty | Thomas | 20 April 1847 | 15 July 1863 |
| Hardesty | William G. | 20 March 1817 | 2 May 1889 |
| Hawthorne | Charles T. | 19 March 1863 | 26 November 1933 |
| Hawthorne | Jennie T. | 30 September 1858 | 29 October 1908 |
| Hawthorne | John B. | 20 October 1816 | 17 February 1894 |
| Hawthorne | Kate L. | 30 March 1856 | 10 September 1897 |
| Holden | Sabra E. | 30 November 1838 | 31 January 1867 |
| Hunsicker | Ann Eve | c. 1770 | 30 April 1859 |
| Hunsicker | Michael S. | 20 September 1798 | 9 June 1872 |
| Hunsicker | Peter | 1816 | |
| Hunsicker | Rebecca K. | 22 June 1808 | 5 February 1888 |
| Huyett | Abraham | c. 1789 | 3 June 1862 |
| Huyett | Elizabeth H. | 23 March 1794 | 29 August 1824 |
| Huyett | Eva R. | 23 December 1793 | 25 April 1866 |
| Huyett | James J. | 3 March 1844 | 3 November 1862 |
| Huyett | John | 2 November 1785 | 1 October 1859 |
| Huyett | Sidney | 6 November 1850 | 8 December 1861 |
| Jobe | Bessie H. | 13 April 1868 | 24 Feburary 1869 |
| Jobe | Laura T. | 2 November 1845 | 6 July 1869 |
| Jones | Elizabeth | c. 1794 | 7 July 1862 |
| Jones | Marian | 28 November 1876 | |
| Jones | Mary Jane | 10 June 1820 | 4 August 1865 |
| Jones | Maryetta | 11 March 1816 | 11 April 1858 |
| Jones | Matthew | c. 1776 | 21 August 1850 |
| Jones | Thomas | 27 May 1817 | 3 April 1879 |
| Kimmell | John Nicholas | 1821 | 1900 |
| Kimmell | Nancy | 1828 | 1904 |
| Kirby | Rosy B. | 18 December 1874 | 22 January 1905 |
| Lauck | Emma A. | 17 March 1851 | 17 October 1876 |
| Lincoln | Mary E. | 1907 | |
| Louthan | Alice L. | 31 July 1883 | 25 February 1885 |
| Louthan | Eva | 25 February 1882 | |
| Louthan | Katie M. | 16 October 1857 | 11 September 1885 |
| Marvin | Elizabeth | 22 November 1842 | |
| Marvin | William | c. 1759 | 23 April 1834 |
| Mayers | John | 16 November 1786 | 6 April 1844 |
| Mayers | Rebecca Jane | 10 July 1825 | 4 December 1831 |
| Mayers | Sarah A.P. | 1 May 1829 | 23 June 1907 |
| Mayers | Stephen Horace | 28 April 1827 | 18 July 1893 |
| Mayers | Violet P. | 6 September 1799 | 7 February 1869 |
| Mayers | William H.H. | 13 December 1837 | 3 June 1884 |
| McAtee | Mabel V. | 18 October 1880 | 6 March 1893 |
| McAtee | Mary E. | 26 May 1843 | 26 May 1882 |
| McCormick | Aby G. D. | c. 1828 | 22 August 1849 |
| McCormick | Amelior | ||
| McCormick | George L. | 26 May 1794 | 23 June 1848 |
| McFillen | Sarah R. | 19 April 1855 | 1 March 1919 |
| McFillen | Smith | 10 January 1843 | 26 December 1910 |
| Monroe | Albert M. | 25 November 1840 | 10 May 1913 |
| Monroe | John J. | 1808 | 1878 |
| Monroe | John W.T. | 18 April 1872 | 11 April 1881 |
| Monroe | Laura V. | 1844 | 1873 |
| Monroe | Mary A. | 1 March 1805 | 11 September 1896 |
| Monroe | William Price | 17 October 1856 | |
| Nichols | Beulah S. | ||
| Nichols | John C. | 1912 | 1938 |
| Pierce | Beauford E. | 2 April 1879 | 11 August 1914 |
| Pierce | Frank H. | 25 November 1900 | 29 July 1901 |
| Pierce | Lula Best | 10 December 1865 | 4 May 1868 |
| Pierce | Mary | 1838 | 1904 |
| Pierce | Newton | c. 1833 | 20 September 1897 |
| Pope | Coonrod | c. 1820 | 24 March 1895 |
| Pope | Elizabeth | 10 January 1833 | 21 August 1909 |
| Pope | Michael | 23 August 1828 | 4 March 1914 |
| Pope | c. 1823 | 18 February 1891 | |
| Poston | R.T. | 13 March 1859 | 21 June 1887 |
| Reed | Susan | c. 1772 | 7 September 1828 |
| Reed | William | c. 1762 | 4 September 1839 |
| Riely | Cornelia Swann | 31 January 1858 | 22 March 1863 |
| Riely | Edward Swann | 17 May 1856 | 16 February 1858 |
| Riely | Mary Virginia | 17 September 1870 | 27 September 187? |
| Riely | Virginia Swann | 17 December 1831 | 3 September 1885 |
| Riely | William A. | 17 November 1829 | 9 August 1905 |
| Roberts | Elizabeth C. | 16 December 1830 | 15 August 1904 |
| Routzong | Ezra | October 1830 | 3 September 1890 |
| Rowland | John | c. 1803 | 15 February 1880 |
| Rowland | Lydia A. | 11 February 1810 | 26 May 1895 |
| Rowland | Thomas J. | 19 November 1829 | 14 July 1901 |
| Shreck | Charles N. | 28 February 1889 | 4 March 1889 |
| Shreck | Joseph | c. 1863 | 16 May 1901 |
| Smith | Elizabeth | 12 May 1830 | 23 July 1865 |
| Smith | Ellie H. | 29 December 1859 | 31 January 1878 |
| Smith | Joseph | 24 November 1802 | 27 November 1869 |
| Smith | Mary A. | 3 March 1788 | 8 January 1868 |
| Smith | Paul | c. 1798 | 2 June 1868 |
| Swann | Ginnie M. | 1 October 1871 | 11 September 1880 |
| Swann | Margaret | c. 1789 | 3 January 1867 |
| Swartz | C.V.S. | 5 February 1879 | 16 April 1879 |
| Swartz | Harry Edison | 20 May 1895 | 29 October 1897 |
| Swartz | M.E.S. | 3 January 1876 | 8 August 1879 |
| West | Ann Elizabeth | c. 1826 | 10 May 1851 |
| Whittington | Simon R. | 10 March 1864 | 21 November 1894 |
| Willingham | Adeline | 13 October 1829 | 23 December 1888 |
| Willingham | Eliza | 16 December 1858 | 14 April 1927 |
| Willingham | John Wesley | 11 October 1859 | 9 November 1906 |
| Wood | Elizabeth S. | 10 May 1810 | 17 May 1831 |
| Young | c. 1852 | 30 June 1882 |
Stone's Chapel Memorial Association 